M's - Tigers APPROVED

[msgm]

Mariners Get:
Fausto Carmona ($1M) (6)
Tigers 2012 First Round Pick

Tigers Get:
Brian Matusz ($0.5M) (2)

I accept. Not sure about Matusz, he may be a solid starter but who knows? He's on a bad team and wasn't amazing last year. I like Carmona and think that he finally "figured it out" last year. He was very consistent posting nearly identical pre and post all star break stats. A first round pick is really nice as well.

[TigerzGM]

I accept. Carmona may be better this year but I like Matusz better long term.

[cmill78]

I still don't get why people like Carmona so much. He is always high 3's to mid 4's ERA his K per 9 is not good (due to being a sinkerballer) and to make matters worse, he pitches for the Indians so wins aren't even a realistic stat. Matusz showed last year that his stuff has "ace" written all over it. But pitching is hard to come by in this league.

Approve

[Dodgers GM]

Approve.

[pirates]

Approve

[styles1111]

I approve

[Nick(Cubs)]

approve